Saturday, January 10, 2015

Anti-Semitism Case Study: Jews, Muslims and France

An aspect of the terrorism by self-identified radical Islamists in France this week is the virulent anti-Semitism  in the attack on the kosher store, evidenced by the statement by the terrorist Amedy Coulibaly  "when the broadcaster asked him why he had decided to attack that particular supermarket, he replied he wanted to target “some Jews.”

This anti-Semitism has been significant recently among Muslims, in Islamic teachings and especially among French Muslims.

Below are several articles extensively discussing this and the failure of French and Islamic authorities to take action, especially in light of the incitement by some Islamic leaders, even their use of religious justification for anti-Semitism.

These articles raise serious questions about the hatred that is anti-Semitism, Islamic teachings and how we can appropriately and skillfully respond to various events and reactions. What insures and supports safety and non-harming? What reduces hatred? What supports and nurtures true peace?

Here are the articles: 

http://tabletmag.com/tag/frances-toxic-hate:

http://www.wsj.com/articles/frances-jews-shudder-over-being-targeted-for-attackagain-1420850789

http://tabletmag.com/scroll/188204/the-frightening-reality-for-the-jews-of-france

Even BBC seems to be confused about anti-Semitism and uses its own political agenda to question and even justify these attacks.

http://tabletmag.com/scroll/188231/bbc-anchor-suggests-french-jews-to-blame-for-palestinian-suffering

And here two short reports with embedded video about the responses of the French Jewish community to these attacks:

http://tabletmag.com/scroll/188225/two-scenes-from-the-grand-synagogue-of-paris

http://www.wsj.com/articles/french-jews-consider-attacks-harrowing-consequences-1421089064?mod=WSJ_hp_RightTopStories

And here is a facebook website of attempts at Jewish Muslim reconciliation, with positive and negative comments:

https://www.facebook.com/theisraelproject/posts/10153829291187316:0

As a part of almost contradictory aspects of Islam, anti-Semitism has a long history in Islam.  Serendipitously, we have two articles that focus on the Prophet Muhammad who "might justly be described as the Jekyll and Hyde of historical biography." The first is a review of  The Lives of Muhammad by Kecia Ali, Harvard,which opens with the following description of Muhammad, "devout Muslims see him as the model for human behavior, non-Muslims have seen him as lustful, barbarous or worse." 

http://www.wsj.com/articles/book-review-the-lives-of-muhammad-by-kecia-ali-1420841587 

The second is an essay by a scholar concerning the history of Muhmmad which likewise raises questions about the traditional account of the origins of Islam:

http://www.wsj.com/articles/when-i-questioned-the-history-of-muhammad-1420821462 

As I said earlier, some these articles raise serious questions about the hatred that is anti-Semitism, Islamic teachings and how we can skillfully and appropriately respond to various events and reactions. 

Do you have any clarity regarding what insures and supports safety and non-harming? 

Since in this ever-changing world there are many sources of incitement and hatred, as these articles demonstrate, we are left with the ongoing question, what reduces hatred? 

And for our life practice, in all the many forms it takes, what can we do which supports and nurtures true peace? 
 




http://www.wsj.com/articles/laure-mandeville-obama-and-the-refusal-to-call-a-cat-a-cat-1422232092#livefyre-comment